Case Study

Case Study: Swatch and the Global Watch Industry Essay
The Swatch Group had many early on successes due to repositioning strategies and a boost from acquisitions. On the surface, the Swatch Group was the world’s leading manufacturer of watches in the late 1990’s. They had 14 percent of the world market share and it appeared that gross sales and net profits were on the rise; however, under the covers, it was a much different story. Swatch was facing a myriad of issues that needed to be resolved in order for success to prevail. Management issues were plaguing Swatch; multiple key figures stepped down from the board in the mid 1990’s citing the CEO’s inability to listen to his staff. In addition to the management issues, Swatch was also facing fierce competition in many market spaces, including the largest consumer base space, the United States.
In addition to lack of market penetration in the United States, Swatch had too many products, which equally distracted buyers and sellers. Lastly, manufacturing costs continued to soar in Switzerland, the Swatch Group’s home base. Other competitors were quickly cutting their costs by moving manufacturing overseas. The Swatch Group was at a crossroad; the strategy that had worked so well in the early 1990’s was no longer viable – the question now was what to do about it?
Management Issues and Potential Resolutions
Although Swatch faced many issues, internal dissension can be the quickest death of a company. Hayek needs to ensure the people chosen to replace the board member’s who stepped down are able to handle his leadership style. Equally as important as selecting a high-performing executive team, Hayek need’s to realize that traditional organizational principles of functional hierarchies will inevitably lead to rifts in management. This is a social issue that Hayek needs to address. If ex-board members continue to bad mouth Swatch it could have an impact on sales. To address this issue, Hayek needs to improve his leadership style and management model to actively involve his staff. As an employee, even an executive employee, being flat out told what you have to do all the time is often the ingredient for an unhealthy work environment, especially when trying to implement change. However, when employees are involved in making a decision it is often easier to put into action the decision that was made.
There is sometimes a higher acceptance of the decision when it comes from the ground up and there is a higher probability that the decision will be executed efficiently. The outcome of such a change will inevitably be positive. When Hayek has more then one person getting together trying to solve a problem, he will have an increased chance at a better solution then if he were trying to solve it himself. The employees bring a lot to the meeting room with them. For instance, they may have “inside information” about why production is faltering. By creating a high-performing executive team that works as a cohesive unit versus “he has to be the big boss alone, and can never share opinions” unit, the Swatch Group should begin to see an improvement in the softer issues, such as employee satisfaction, higher executive employee retention, and a more open communication model.
Competitive and Product Mix Issues and Potential Resolutions
The Swatch group as a whole had an unparalleled ability to provide consumers with a wide range of products in all market segments. They could provide hi-tech watches that functioned as ski passes, fashion watches such as the Swatch, or an exquisite diamond studded precious metal watch – Swatch provided products at all extremes. However, certain product lines were more successful then others. The Swatch watch in particular was struggling to gain market share in the United States and elsewhere for several reasons including fickle consumer behavior and a product line that was daunting to consumers and resellers.
The Swatch product was quickly loosing its competitive edge against other players such as Fossil, Guess, Timex and Seiko. Resellers were dropping like flies and consumers felt like Swatch had saturated the market with too many products. Worse of all, consumer perception was that Swatch was a fad. Swift decisions need to be made to reverse this before the brand becomes part of a MTV or VH1 “I love the 90’s” television show. Luckily, most of the decisions to be made regarding product mix have very little impact socially and ethically.
Omega (part of the Swatch Group portfolio of brands), was facing a similar demise in the early 1990’s and successfully repositioned itself and became a major profit driver for the group. It achieved this by carefully selecting its marketing programs and drastically trimming its product line from 2,500 to 130. This strategy needs to be applied to Swatch, which focuses on the basic and middle-priced market. This is supported by the fact that the number of resellers dropped from 3,000 in the early 1990’s to 1,200 in 1998. Swatch needs to apply a SWOT analysis and determine which product lines are successful in this market space and drop the remaining products. In addition, the Swatch Group needs to look at their consumer base and determine if it would be profitable to launch a new product line that captures past consumers who have now progressed to the next stage of their lives and are desiring a more expensive and sophisticated watch.
A marketing campaign needs to be chosen that helps attract new consumers in the basic and middle price market focusing on the smaller number of brands and a separate campaign should be created that focuses on keeping their existing customer base. These campaigns should be replicated to other countries to ensure the Swatch brand remains visible. Neither of these resolutions will be easy to implement; however, if done successfully Swatch will decrease their production costs because there are fewer product lines and increase their sales based on marketing campaigns to two separate groups: new customers and existing customers.
Manufacturing Issues and Potential Resolutions
Driven by high demand, offshore manufacturing centers are appearing throughout the world. Many of the Swatch Group’s competitors have switched their manufacturing to centers overseas and decreased their fixed costs, which resulted in an increase in profit.
The Swatch Group had always remained committed to its home base, partly because their home base possessed centuries of expertise in watch making and partly because a timepiece cannot be stamped with “Swiss Made” unless at least 50% of Swiss manufactured products by value are present in the timepiece. Although the mix of factors raising the possibility of outsourcing varies from company to company, there are a few themes that the Swatch Group needs to explore regarding the pressures to outsource. The Swatch Group needs to recognize that general concerns regarding cost and quality are the main drivers for outsourcing. In addition, outsourcing can turn a fixed cost into a variable cost, which will significantly help a company with varying volumes.
Although most businesses can benefit hugely through outsourcing or manufacturing in another country, the Swatch Group needs to determine if it will be successful and profitable for them. Outsourcing a portion of their value chain is not a quick-fix response to production costs or performance lags. Additionally, the choices for outsourcing locations are many, they are not all equal, differing in several critical areas. Selecting the right option requires balancing factors such as cultural affinity, geopolitical risk, cost, and resource availability.
To help narrow their focus in their analysis, initially, the Swatch Group should look to India for their outsource location. India has a large talent pool of skilled, experienced watch workers. These workers have hands-on experience supporting Titan industries. Titan is continuing to grow as a company and the pace of resource expansion is dramatically improving in keeping up with current as well as future technologies. Additionally, the Swatch Group should center their outsourcing attention to the assembly portion of the value added chain. This will ensure that 50% of the manufactured parts are still completed in Switzerland.
The design, marketing, and most of manufacturing of the watches still remain where the expertise is located. The assembly of a watch is an extremely repeatable and easily controllable task, which will increase the success for outsourcing. Outsourcing assembly to India will have many positive effects for the Swatch Group. Cost reduction remains the primary objective of outsourcing; the Swatch Group will have the ability to provide a good at a lower cost and should be able to make the assembly cost more predictable and controlled.
Ethically and socially, outsourcing has a caused many individuals and increase in job insecurity. Lower labor standards in other countries are forcing many companies to outsource much of their manufacturing. This is especially unsettling for individuals who lack the skills to make themselves difficult to replace, such as in manufacturing. If the Swatch Group decides to outsource assembly, there will be no easy way to redeploy the assembly workers. They can setup a redeployment pool for those resources and try to redeploy them elsewhere in the company. However, if this is not possible, a business decision will have to be made to lay those workers off. The utmost sensitivity will be required as it is possible that generations of families have worked for the Swatch Group. The Swatch Group will need to carefully balance the outsourcing cost reduction possibilities with the social ramifications that may exist.
There are many issues facing the Swatch Group and there is no right way to solve any of the issues. Each issue comes laden with ethical and social consequences that will also impact the company. The Swatch Group will need to take steps to ensure that international integration does not cause domestic social disintegration. Regardless of how the issues are resolve, the greatest challenge is going to be finding the right balance between markets and societies.

Case Study: Mrs. Franklin-Jones is a patient moving to the cardiac step-down unit today from Cardiac Intensive Care unit. Her recovery has improved as expected. She was admitted from the Emergency Room where she presented with a heart attack a week ago. She tells Nurse Julie Hernandez about the pain in her chest and her blood pressure, as she is settling into her new room. She states that she doesn’t always take her medication or read the information that comes from the clinic about her diet. Family history reveals that her mother had high blood pressure also. Mrs. Franklin-Jones states that she doesn’t take the best care of herself. She states that she may have to learn a new way of cooking from what she was used to in Jamaica. Tomas is unemployed and has more time, so he may have to do the cooking, she says. Mrs. Franklin-Jones works two jobs and doesn’t have much time between working at the school cafeteria and her new housecleaning job. Her sister will be visiting from Jamaica and bringing bush tea with her for Mrs. Franklin-Jones.

CASE STUDY: “No Bats in the Belfry: The Origin of White-Nose Syndrome in Little Brown Bats”
by Dechaine and Johnson
Part I – The Basic Question
Imagine going out for a brisk winter snowshoe and suddenly stumbling upon hundreds of bat carcasses littering the forest floor. Unfortunately, this unsettling sight has become all too common in the United States (Figure 1). White-nose syndrome (WNS), first discovered in 2006, has now spread to 20 states and has led to the deaths of over 5.5 million bats (as of January 2012). WNS is a disease caused by the fungus, Pseudogymnoascus destructans. Bats infected with WNS develop white fuzz on their noses (Figure 2, next page) and often exhibit unnatural behavior, such as flying outside during the winter when they should be hibernating.
WNS affects at least six different bat species in the United States and quickly decimates bat populations (colony mortality is commonly greater than 90%). Scientists have predicted that if deaths continue at the current rate, several bat species will become locally extinct within 20 years. Bats provide natural pest control by eating harmful insects, such as crop pests and disease carrying insect species, and losing bat populations would have devastating consequences for the U.S. economy.
Researchers have sprung into action to study how bats become infected with and transmit P. destructans, but a key component of this research is determining where the fungus came from in the first place. Some have suggested that it is an invasive species from a different country while others think it is a North American fungal species that has recently become better able to cause disease. In this case study, we examine the origin of P. destructans causing WNS in North America.
Some Other Important Observations
• WNS was first documented at four cave sites in New York State in 2006.
• The fungus can be spread among bats by direct contact or spores can be transferred between caves by humans (on clothing) or other animals.
• European strains of the fungus occur in low levels across Europe but have led to few bat deaths there.
• Bats with WNS frequently awake during hibernation, causing them to use important fat reserves, leading to death.
Figure 1. Many bats dead in winter from white-nose syndrome.

Answer the following questions.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!

order now

What is a hypothesis?
A hypothesis is an educated guess during a project or an experiment.
2. What is a null hypothesis?
A null hypothesis is a type of hypothesis that proposes that no significance exists in a set of given observations.It is is a hypothesis which someone tries to disprove, reject or nullify an observation or idea.
3. What is the basic question of this study and why is it interesting?
The basic question of this study is ” is the European strain causing the WNS attacks on the North American bats”. It is interesting because if the european strain is killing the birds in North America then why isn’t it having the same effect on the European birds.
4. What specific testable hypotheses can you develop to explain the observations and answer the basic question of this study? Write at least two alternative hypotheses.
1. the european strain of WNS is the same as the North American strain of WNS
2. the european strain of WNs is different from the North American strain
5. What predictions about the effects of European strains of P. destructans on North American bats can you make if your hypotheses are correct? Write at least one prediction for each of your hypotheses.
If my first hypothesis is right then the European strain of WNS is killing more North American bats because of environmental or climatic factors. If my second hypothesis is right then the bats in North American are dying more than the European bats because the two funguses are completely different.
Figure 2. White fuzz on the muzzle of a little brown bat indicating infection by the disease.

Part II – The Hypothesis
As discussed in Part I, researchers had preliminary data suggesting that the pathogen causing WNS is an invasive fungal species (P. destructans) brought to North America from Europe. They had also observed that P. destructans occurs on European bats but rarely causes their death.
Preliminary research also suggested that one reason that bats have been dying from WNS is that the disorder arouses them from hibernation, causing the bats to waste fat reserves flying during the winter when food is not readily available.
These observations led researchers to speculate that European P. destructans will affect North American bat hibernation at least as severely as does North American P. destructans (Warnecke et al. 2012).
6. Explicitly state the researchers’ null (H0) and alternative hypotheses (HA) for this study.
Null Hypothesis is that the European strain will affect the North American bat hibernation at least as severely as does North American strain.
Alternative Hypothesis is that the disorder arouses the bats from hibernation causing them to waste fat reserves during the winter when food is not readily available which eventually causes them to die.

7. Describe an experiment you could use to differentiate between these hypotheses (H0 and HA).
a group of healthy bats could be separated into groups of trials where one group is injected with the european strain and the other is injected with the north american straian and the last group will be the control group under the same conditions.
Part III – Experiments and Observations
In 2010, Lisa Warnecke and colleagues (2012) isolated P. destructans fungal spores from Europe and North America. They collected 54 male little brown bats (Myotis lucifugus) from the wild and divided these bats equally into three treatment groups.
• Group 1 was inoculated with the North American P. destructans spores (NAGd treatment).
• Group 2 was inoculated with the European P. destructans spores (EUGd treatment).
• Group 3 was inoculated using the inoculation serum with no spores (Control treatment).
All three groups were put into separate dark chambers that simulated the environmental conditions of a cave. All bats began hibernating within the first week of the study.
The researchers used infrared cameras to examine the bats’ hibernation over four consecutive intervals of 26 days each. They then used the cameras to determine the total number of times a bat was aroused from hibernation during each interval.
8. Use the graph below to predict what the results will look like if the null hypothesis is supported. The total arousal counts in the control treatment at each interval is graphed for you (open bars). Justifiy your predictions.

9. Use the graph below to predict what the results will look like if the null hypothesis is rejected. The total arousal counts in the control treatment at each interval is graphed for you (open bars). Justify your predictions.

Part IV – Results
Figure 3 (below) shows the real data from the study. There is no data for interval 4 bats that were exposed to the European P. destructans (gray bar) because all of the bats in that group died.

10. How do your predictions compare with the experimental results? Be specific.
My predictions was relatively close with the experimental results. In the first interval my predictions were 30 arousal counts for the North American strain and on the second interval my predictions were the same as the experimental results. On the third interval my predictions were that the European strain will be around 120 but in the experimental results it was 110 and for the fourth interval i predicted that the control will be 40 arousal counts but it was around 22 in the experimental results.
11. Do the results support or reject the null hypothesis?
The results supports the null hypothesis

12. If the European P. destructans is causing WNS in North America, how come European bats aren’t dying from the same disease?
This could be because of an environmental or climatic factor which might be present in North America and not in Europe.

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. 2012. White-Nose Syndrome. Available at: Last accessed December 20, 2013.
Warnecke, L., et al. 2012. Inoculation of bats with European Geomyces destructans supports the novel pathogen hypothesis for the origin of white-nose syndrome. PNAS Online Early Edition: doi/10.1073/pnas.1200374109. Last accessed December 20, 2013.


I'm Belinda!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out